The Best 4 Slice Toaster: Top Contenders, Considerations, And More!

By Rose | Small Appliances

Jun 13
The Best 4 Slice Toaster: Top Contenders, Considerations, And More!

Toasting is one of the most delicious ways to prepare your food. The sound of a toaster in the morning wakes our senses (and appetites)! It doesn't matter if you want to have a white loafer or a bagel barmy, the best 4-slice toaster will create all of these delicacies easily and hassle-free!

How To Choose The Best 4 Slice Toaster

Toasting is a precise combination of grilling and drying. The balance between these two cooking methods allows the toaster to prepare a variety of different food. A high-quality toaster can cater for any bread. From wholemeal to fresh bread, the toaster should be able to turn them into something delicious for you!

The market today offers a lot of options, and most of them vary in design, style, and price. Your choice may boil down to your own preferences, but there are specific considerations that you need to keep in mind when shopping for a toaster. We will discuss them in more detail later.

But now let's introduce the best toasters that we've tested. Among the dozens of available products out there, only these devices left a lasting impression on us. That's why we highly recommend that you try them out first before jumping to other options!

More...

We can already smell the delicious toast that comes from these toasters. If you are curious about their respective features and qualities, then take the time to read all of our detailed reviews, so that you know what to expect from these high-quality toasters! So what are you waiting for? Read on!

Best 4 Slice Toasters: Features, Performance And More!

1. Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster

Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster Review

Image from Amazon.com

The Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster has a simple but sleek design that is a perfect fit for any modern kitchen design. It is pretty compact as well, so you can save a lot of counter space! It has a robust die-cast metal body that comes with a Cool-Touch feature. As a result, you won't get scorched even if you touch the body of the toaster while it is on.

This 1,600-watt 4-slice toaster is very energy efficient. This is pretty surprising, considering the unit is undeniably powerful. It can toast quickly and efficiently as well, so your bread won't come out half-cooked or overcooked with this toaster!

We also love the fact that this toaster can accommodate various bread sizes! With this feature, you don’t have to worry about fitting it in anymore!

When it comes to its operation, this toaster won't give you any trouble. It has a LED indicator that will tell you about the progress of your toasting, so the guessing part is removed. It also features a "Sound Alert" that activates once the toasting is done. You can adjust the volume of the alarm, depending on your preferences.

Pros

  • Classy and modern design.
  • Compact and rugged construction.
  • The body has "Cool Touch" technology.
  • It can cater all bread sizes and shapes.
  • Low power consumption.

Cons

  • An expensive price tag.

2. Cuisinart 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster CPT-180

Cuisinart 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster CPT-180 Review

Image from Amazon.com

The Cuisinart is a reputable name when it comes to kitchen appliances. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that their toasters are perfectly fine as well! In this article, we feature two of their 4-slice toasters. The first one is the Cuisinart 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster. Just like the Breville, it has a premium and rugged construction, but it is pretty affordable too. That's a factor that might seal the deal for you!

One of the most impressive features is its dual-panel controls. Specifically, each of the two slots have a separate control on them. Therefore, you can make this one as a 2-slice toaster as well. This intuitive design allows you to toasts different types of bread simultaneously. Here are the controls of the toaster that you can configure: browning (6 settings), dual reheating, defrosting, and bagel. All of these are in the form of buttons (except for the browning, which is a knob), so accessing them is easy.

This toaster also offers 1-1/2 inch wide slots so it can cater most bread sizes, and features an extra-lift lever and crumb tray. Finally, its various LED indicators make it very convenient to use.

Pros

  • Compact and rugged design.
  • Can operate a 2-slice toaster.
  • Comes with various toasting controls.
  • Has  a crumb tray.
  • Wide slots for bread.

Cons

  • Thin cord.
  • The surface doesn't have a cooling feature (so don't touch it while it is operating).

3. Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster CPT-440

Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster CPT-440 Review

Image from Amazon.com

It would be a huge blunder if this 4-slice toaster didn't make it on this list. After all, the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster has an exceptional performance that any homeowners would love! Just like its cousin, it has a stainless-steel construction. It feels so rugged, we wouldn't be surprised if it lasted for several years. It also has a motorized lift that improves its overall operation.

We believe the Cuisinart CPT-440 is not only way better than the CPT-180 when it comes to functionality, but is also way better than most of its competitors on the market today. It features an LCD countdown timer that enables to indicate the progress of toasting and has a perfect choice for bagel toasting, as well as an enhanced reheating and defrosting options. Moreover, when the bagel control is activated, you can guarantee that only one side of the bread gets toasted.

Just like the CPT-180, this device can also act as a 2-slice toaster, as each of the two slots have a separate control on them. It is pretty functional with an energy-efficient approach if you don't want to use full power or just want to eat one or two slices of bread.

Pros

  • Its cord wraps easily.
  • A compact and robust design.
  • LCD timer with blue backlight improves it functionality.
  • Easy to operate and control.
  • Enhanced bagel toasting is truly impressive.

Cons

  • It still doesn't have a cooling feature on its surface.

4. West Bend 4-Slot Egg and Muffin Toaster

West Bend 4-Slot Egg and Muffin Toaster Review

Image from Amazon.com

If you want a versatile option, then we give you the West Bend 4-Slot Egg and Muffin Toaster. For us, it is among the most innovative toasters that we've ever encountered. Apart from being a toaster, it can also act as a meat warmer and egg cooker. Therefore, you can prepare your daily breakfast with just a single machine! There's no need to worry about its power consumption, as this device has only a 1,800-watt rating!

You could never say the West Bend Toaster is a flimsy product, as it still comes with the necessary toasting functions. It can also defrost and reheat bread and prepare croissants and bagels as well! In fact, you can control the color of your toast on this machine. Depending on your preferences, you can either select light or dark toasting.

In addition, the cooker can prepare different egg recipes, such as scrambled eggs and poached eggs. The egg tray can cater for up to eight eggs, which is good news for every household out there, and the meat tray warms vegetables and fruits, depending on your preference.

Pros

  • It's a 3-in-1 toaster.
  • It is still compact and saves a lot of counter space.
  • Basic toasting functions are still present.
  • Energy efficient.
  • Comes with a plastic cup for exact water measurements.

Cons

  • There is a noticeable water vapor leak from the egg boiler on the countertop.
  • Its operation is pretty complicated.

5. Smeg 4 Slice Toaster

Smeg 4 Slice Toaster Review

Image from Amazon.com

The Smeg 4 Slice Toaster is one beautiful machine. Apart from producing tasty, flavorful toasted bread, it can be a sweet decoration for your kitchen. It has a sleek and space-sensitive design that makes it an excellent toaster for any home setup.

The slots are pretty wide and there is a self-centering mechanism that guarantees your bread will be evenly and perfectly toasted. It also has an automated pop-up operation so that you can easily take out the bread after toasting. You will also love the steel tray for crumb removable. The tray is detachable as well! Therefore, cleaning won't be a problem!

The browning feature has six settings. Therefore, you can control the color of the toast. Moreover, the reheat, bagel, and defrost settings are pre-configured to ensure the best possible toast!

As well as its the Retro Style Aesthetic, this Smeg toaster is also available in a Chrome version. You'll definitely want to check this one out!

Pros

  • Sleek and classy design.
  • Anti-slip base.
  • Comes with six browning levels.
  • The slots have a self-centering mechanism.
  • Easy to clean.

Cons

  • No noticeable drawbacks.

Things To Consider Before Buying A 4-Slice Toaster

We have now presented our recommended products for a 4-slice toaster. So now is the perfect time to explain more about these machines. We all know that a toaster creates our favorite bagels and toasted recipes. Instead of doing it manually, it can efficiently do this job without you lifting any finger.

Some of your may still be dubious about whether this kitchen appliance is necessary or not. After all, there are lot of ways to prepare food and different varieties of food we can eat.

Reasons Why A Toaster Is Essential

Reasons Why A Toaster Is Essential

Convenience

Well, from our end, we are convinced it is necessary. The first reason is the convenience it brings. We don't just like muffins, baguettes, and waffles because of their flavor, it's also because they are easy and quick to prepare. Most of us have day jobs, which means the morning rush. A quick and healthy breakfast certainly improves our day, regardless of how hectic it is. A toaster can give you this benefit, so why hesitate?

If you have a large family, then you should go for a 4-slice toaster, which provides huge servings very quickly!

Variety

There are a lot of bread-related recipes that you can cook with a toaster. It is up to you how much exploration you want to do. For example, you can do avocado toast and pesto sandwiches in a toaster. They are easy to prepare and great for lunch and afternoon breaks. Toasters are also masters in making crostini.

For those who love bagels, a 4-slice toaster can create Huevos rancheros and Apple pumpkin bagels. So toasters can bring you a world full of flavors!

They Are Not Costly

Many of you are reluctant to buy a toaster because there is an ongoing misconception that they are pretty expensive. Well, some of them are but they also give you value for money. Of course, there are also a lot of cost-friendly options out there.

  • Here is the golden rule: There is no need to choose an expensive toaster. Instead, look for one that offers the features and controls you want. By narrowing down your selection, you will definitely find a product that is right for your wallet!

Choosing A Toaster: Basic Considerations

Toaster or Toaster Oven?

Some people get confused about these two machines. Although they both can do "toasting", they are really different, especially when we are talking about functionality.

  • If you want to toast bread, then go with a toaster, as toast from a toaster is browner and more even.
  • But if you want to do broiling, roasting, and melting, then go for a toaster oven.

Capacity

Always consider the number of people that you are serving. If you are just alone, then a 2-slice toaster will suit you perfectly. But if you are in household, then get a 4-slice toaster. For huge events and gatherings, a 4-slice toaster is insufficient and you need to get a toaster oven.

The standard toaster oven has a 6-slice capacity. Therefore, it is an efficient, time-saving option for large servings.

Size

The size of the oven doesn't always determine the capacity to cater for all types of bread shapes and sizes. Instead, inspect the size of the slots (the horizontal openings of the toaster) and check if they are big enough to accommodate any ingredient you put into it.

It is also great to have a mechanism that automatically centers the bread to assure the toast is even and perfect.


Features

Consistency in Browning

A toaster should be able to brown your bread to different hues. This "coloring" should also be consistent. This is a simple but effective indicator of the machine's quality. If the toaster can produce similar shades in all the batch it produces, then you should get that toaster, no matter what!

Countdown Timer

A toaster should be ergonomic and intuitive. Its operation should not be complicated and quirky. Most of the old toaster models didn't come with a feature that told you the overall progress of the toasting. This led to overcooking or undercooking. Fortunately, manufacturers have now addressed this problem.

You should choose toasters with countdown timers because it means there is no need for you to guess anymore.

Controls

When it comes to controls, toasters with dials and touchpads are best, as they offer convenience and are ease to operate. But make sure the controls have clear labels so that you know what you are pressing all the time!

Ease of Cleaning

It is inevitable that a toaster produces a lot of crumbs. Therefore, it is best to have a crumb tray, which catches those falling crumbs and other bread residues.

This tray should be removable. Do not choose devices with trays that are connected and hinged to the toaster as they are very hard to clean.

Try to find a toaster with a non-stick interior surface. If a toaster has small holes and vents on it, then it is a good product. These openings will capture any grime and grease that the toaster produces.

Our Top Picks

Final Verdict

A 4-slice toaster is an appliance that your kitchen needs and deserves, there is no doubt about that. Apart from the tasty recipes you can create with it, it also offers you convenience which is pretty rare in food preparation.

Best 4 Slice Toaster: My Best Picks

My Best Picks


We deem that the best 4-slice toaster is the Cuisinart CPT-440. We've already mentioned how efficient it is when preparing bread toasts and other similar recipes. It also has huge slots to cater for various bread sizes.

If you are looking for a budget-friendly toaster, then you should check out the Cuisinart CPT-180. It is pretty affordable with good features and a strong construction.

For those who want an innovative toaster, the West Bend Toaster is the right choice!

But we would still encourage you to check all of these toasters yourself, as you won't know which one works best for you until you try all of the possible options.

Also, go and check out our separate article for the best 2-slice toasters! We are sure that you'll enjoy it!

Did you learn from this article? Which of these toasters do you like the most? Tell us your answers in the comment section below!

The Best 4 Slice Toaster: Top Contenders, Considerations, And More!
5 (32) votes
Follow

About the Author

There’s nothing in this world that excites me more other than cooking. From appetizers to desserts, since then, I’ve always been passionate on making foods.

Leave a Comment:

Leave a Comment: