The Best Silicone Baking Mat For Every Baking Aficionado Out There!

By Rose | Bakeware

Sep 05
The Best Silicone Baking Mat For Every Baking Aficionado Out There!

It is a fact that the quality of your utensils and cooking tools will determine the deliciousness of your food. For example, the presence of a simple tool, like a silicone mat, can make all the difference.

The best silicone baking mat is an essential tool for making cakes and pastries. With this amenity, you can make your presentation less messy and your delicacies more presentable.

Traditionally, baking tends to be messy. Cakes often get disfigured. When the silicone mat was invented, rolling or kneading the dough became a lot easier and your pan no longer needed to be greased.

How To Choose The Best Silicone Baking Mat

There are a lot of choices when it comes to baking silicone mats. The market offers a variety of options which vary in their design, price, and capabilities. However, in this article, we will only feature the best. Here they are!

More...

Each of these baking mats has already been tested by many cake artisans all over the world. In the next section, we will highlight the respective features of each of these baking mats. Just read on!

The Best Silicone Baking Mat Review

Silchef Silicone Non-Stick Baking Mats Review

Image from Amazon.com

Colorful but useful. This is how we describe the silicone baking mats from Silchef. One of their packages will give you three mats. Each of them comes in different sizes which can cater for various applications. You can use the half-sheet mats to cover conventional baking trays and the 1/4-sheet liner is perfect for your toaster, oven, and other minimal servings.

Each of the silicone sheets comes with fiberglass mesh. With this construction, you can expect each of these mats to provide an even and equal distribution of heat. As a result, you can get optimal baking results and guarantee there are no overcooked or undercooked cookies!

With these sheets from Silchef, there is no need for you to invest in sprays and parchment papers. These products are considered to be a "single purchase" tool, which means they are reusable. Just wipe them after you've used them, and they are as good as new again! Of course, these mats are dishwasher safe. Therefore, cleaning them is very convenient!

Pros

  • thumbs-up
    Effective defense against grease.
  • thumbs-up
    Easy to clean (dishwasher safe).
  • thumbs-up
    Come in multiple sizes.
  • thumbs-up
    Promote equal heat distribution.
  • thumbs-up
    Durable and toxic free.

Cons

  • thumbs-down
    No particular drawbacks noticed.

Bake Buddy Jumbo Silicone Pastry Mat Review

Image from Amazon.com

The Bake Buddy Jumbo Silicone Pastry Mat is another great option for a baking sheet. This silicone mat is among the largest we have seen. It is 20 inches x 30 inches. Therefore, it can cover a lot of space on your baking tray and protect your tabletop and countertop effectively! Of course, this also prevents the production of mess and unnecessary cleaning up.

The Bake Buddy has a special construction that allows it to stick to your baking tray. It doesn't wobble compared to most traditional baking mats, so it won't slide off even if you are rolling a fondant or dough. The parts are made from safe materials and it doesn't contain BPAs and other harmful chemicals.

Noticeably, this silicone baking mat has an imprinted conversion and measurement tables on its surface. It is an intuitive design that allows bakers to prepare their ingredients as conveniently as possible. Just by looking at this baking mat, you can try various recipes without breaking sweat!

Pros

  • thumbs-up
    Washable and reusable.
  • thumbs-up
    Easy to store (it can be rolled or folded).
  • thumbs-up
    Comes with a printed measurement tables and temperature chart.
  • thumbs-up
    Doesn't move out of place.
  • thumbs-up
    Doesn't contain harmful chemicals.

Cons

  • thumbs-down
    No particular drawbacks noticed.

Silpat Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat Review

Image from Amazon.com

The Silpat Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat is a convenient choice for any bakers out there. It can instantly provide your baking tray with a non-stick layer, which is essential for preparing dough. You can use it in various recipes because of its versatile construction. In fact, it is way better than any parchment paper and eliminates the need for oil, sprays, and grease. They are messy, after all.

This particular baking mat has a fiberglass mesh construction. Moreover, it is complemented by a food-grade silicone layer. The combination of these two materials can provide optimal heat distribution. Therefore, you can expect that your baking will always yield even results. Furthermore, it prevents both overcooking and undercooking!

Notably, this baking sheet has a rugged construction. It is made from France but has passed US quality regulations and standards. Just like all of the products here, the Silpat doesn't contain any chemicals. It also doesn't interact with the food, even under extreme heat.

Pros

  • thumbs-up
    Usable in the oven, microwave, and freezer.
  • thumbs-up
    Durable and rugged application.
  • thumbs-up
    Reusable.
  • thumbs-up
    Promotes equal heat distribution.
  • thumbs-up
    Sticks well on your baking tray.

Cons

  • thumbs-down
    It is quite challenging to clean.

Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat Sheet Set Review

Image from Amazon.com

Kitzini doesn't lag behind when it comes to making cooking utensils. In fact, their silicone baking mat is one of the most loved options on the market today. One package will give you two non-stick baking mats. Each of these mats have amazing tolerance to extreme heat. You can subject them to up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which is essential for baking purposes.

These mats remove the need for cooking sprays, butter, and oil. Obviously, you don't have to use parchment paper anymore. It will give you a convenient working surface to create different pastries and recipes and sticks well on your baking tray, too. Therefore, the preparation process is very comfortable.

The Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat has a special fiberglass core integrated on its construction. Because of this, you can assure that these mats are and long-lasting. You will also love the fact that it doesn't alter the flavor of your food. Moreover, this utensil is dishwasher safe and reusable. It is indeed an excellent choice for any households!

Pros

  • thumbs-up
    Easy to clean.
  • thumbs-up
    Can resist extreme heat.
  • thumbs-up
    One package gives you two baking sheets.
  • thumbs-up
    Prevents mess in the baking preparation.
  • thumbs-up
    Durable construction.

Cons

  • thumbs-down
    It is too large for some baking trays.
  • thumbs-down
    You need to clean it meticulously.

Adorn Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mats Review

Image from Amazon.com

Adorn is another great producer of high-quality baking mats. The sheets they produce are of a convenient sizes that fit any half-size baking pans, and have a good layout that prevents them from moving. Therefore, you can easily work on the baking mats without too much hassle and mess.

Because of its specialized construction, the Adorn Baking Mats can provide excellent heat distribution, so you can guarantee that all of your food will be baked at the same time. Moreover, this mat has a flexible build and is resistant to wear and tear. It can withstand hundreds and thousands of usages without losing its quality.

All of the parts of the Adorn Baking Mats are made of safe and chemical-free materials. There are no BPAs or other hazardous elements in this product. Furthermore, we can guarantee that it won't interact with your food, regardless of the extreme heat or cold. 

Pros

  • thumbs-up
    Durable, lasts for multiple usages. 
  • thumbs-up
    It doesn't contain harmful chemicals.
  • thumbs-up
    Dishwasher safe.
  • thumbs-up
    Prevents mess and means you do not use grease and oil.
  • thumbs-up
    Works on different recipes.

Cons

  • thumbs-down
    There are still some fitting problems.

Our Ratings

Silicone Baking Mat Basics

After introducing the best options available, it is now the perfect time to highlight some of the fundamental basics that you should know, so that you can easily determine whether a particular silicone baking mat is of good quality or not.

Silicone Baking Mat Basics

First of all, we will define what a baking mat is. Specifically, it is a specialized sheet that you put on your baking tray. It has the same appearance as parchment paper and it replaces the parchment paper, which tends to get messy.

Two Types Of Silicone Baking Mat

There are two types of silicone mats that you can get on the market today.  

  • check
    The first one is the half sheet or the ones that we feature in this article. Half sheets are the ideal choice for making cookies and related pastries as they offer enough space for the preparation and placement of these treats.
  • check
    The second type are rounded and so are perfect for making cakes. It would be good idea to have both kinds in your kitchen.

Benefits Of A Silicone Baking Mat

There are a lot of benefits you can gain by using a baking mat. Traditional parchment papers are slowly being eliminated in commercial baking as cake and cookie parlors find that silicone baking mats are more convenient and give tasty results.

Benefits Of A Silicone Baking Mat

Here are some of the benefits of a silicone baking mat:

Mess Free

In the past, there was a need for grease, oil, or butter because parchment paper doesn't have non-stick properties. As a result, the dough or fondant tended to stick to the paper. Although oil or grease can solve the problem, they produce mess and waste, which is a pet peeve of most bakers out there.

This kind of predicament is avoidable if you use a silicone baking mat. The silicone, together with other materials (e.g. fiberglass mesh), prevents the food and tray from sticking together. It also lessens the amount of time you spend on preparation and cleaning up, as you can remove the ingredients as quickly as possible. 

It Is Healthy

A silicone baking mat doesn't need the help of grease or oil. It can work on its own, so is healthier. There is no need to risk your well-being so that you can eat delicious treats.

Also, parchment paper contains chemicals that, when subjected to extreme heat, might interact with your food. This can either affect the smell or taste of your food and could jeopardize the quality of the treat. A quick trip to the hospital is not a good thing at all.

Economic

Most of the silicone baking mats on the market today have a durable construction. The presence of silicone alone is proof that this utensil will last a long time. Unlike parchment papers, you don't need to throw away the silicone baking mat after using it. You just have to clean it and it is ready again for another serving!

In fact, some of the silicone baking mats out there can last for more than a thousand usages. They might be expensive but in the long run, it allows you to save a lot of money! 

Are All Baking Mats Safe?

This is an important question that we have to address. After all, the safety of your family or customers is on the line here. Every time you shop for a baking mat, make sure that they all pass the strict standards of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), so that you know they are not hiding some dirty secrets.

Of course, silicone can cause health issues if a particular product doesn't regulate the usage or level of its silicone content.

But overall, we consider that most of the silicone baking mats out there are safe to use. You just have to be wary about their construction.

How To Choose The Best Silicone Baking Mat

How To Choose The Best Silicone Baking Mat

Here are the things to consider before you choose a silicone baking mat:

Ruggedness

A silicone baking mat, despite being thin, should be robust and durable. Preparing the dough requires some rigorous hand work. Therefore, your working surface should be stable enough so that you can work conveniently. There is a good chance the flimsy mat will distort once you start rolling the ingredients.

The firmness of the mat also indicates its durability. The sturdier the mat is, the more it can resist wear and tear. This factor just improves its usability and lifespan.

Usability

You should be able to use a silicone baking mat multiple times. All of the products that we have featured here have this characteristic. Some of you might want to settle on a mat that is only suitable for a single use, but that is not a cost-efficient move.

Safety

The silicone baking mat should be able to resist extreme heat and cold. After all, baking requires you to put the dough in an oven or freezer. Otherwise, it will affect the quality and safety of your food.

It should also be dishwasher safe so that you can clean it easily and prevent mold.

Final Verdict

Best Silicone Baking Mat: Our Best Picks

Overall, we consider that a silicone baking mat is a necessity for every household and commercial baker. It improves the efficiency and cleanliness of the baking process. Moreover, it promotes healthy and delectable results. With this tool, you can guarantee that your pastries will taste great!

Among the products we featured, we deem the Silchef Silicone to be the best. It is a package that provides different sizes of baking sheets. Therefore, it is both a convenient and versatile choice.

The Bake Buddy Jumbo Silicone Pastry Mat is another great contender for the top spot. With its large size and intuitive layout, it can enhance the speed and efficiency of your baking. But if you want to explore other options, you are free to try all of these products that we recommend on this list.

Did you learn what you needed from this article? Which of these silicone baking mats do you like the most? Tell us your answers in the comments section below! Enjoy your shopping!

The Best Silicone Baking Mat For Every Baking Aficionado Out There!
5 (27) votes
Follow

About the Author

There’s nothing in this world that excites me more other than cooking. From appetizers to desserts, since then, I’ve always been passionate on making foods.

Leave a Comment:

Leave a Comment: